What would happen if Biden or Trump died?

The two oldest candidates in US history
Biden’s mental fitness has been questioned
The 25th amendment states the VP would replace the president
Timing is everything
The answer would depend on when they die
If they die before the primaries come to an end
If they die after the primaries but before the conventions
The conventions
Each party would decide on their new nominee
Each party has different rules
“Party business”
If they die after the conventions but before Election Day
If they die after Election Day
When does a winning candidate become president-elect?
There is some ambiguity in the law
A situation that would worsen an already tumultuous election
The two oldest candidates in US history
America is preparing for a presidential rematch between the two oldest candidates in US history: 81 year-old president Joe Biden and 77 year-old former president Donald Trump.
Biden’s mental fitness has been questioned
Moreover, Biden’s mental fitness has been recently questioned and Trump being a convicted felon facing further criminal charges, has raised questions about what would happen in case of incapacitation or death of either of them.
The 25th amendment states the VP would replace the president

The 25th amendment of the US Constitution states that if the president dies, the vice president would become president. So if Biden, as the sitting president, were to die, vice-president, Kamala Harris, would assume the powers of the presidency.

Timing is everything

However, timing is everything,  and as the country prepares for the November presidential election, the hypothetical scenario becomes more complicated than Harris replacing Biden.

The answer would depend on when they die
According to Elaine Kamarck, expert on American electoral politics, the answer to what would happen if Trump or Biden die or become completely incapacitated, really depends on when that happens.
If they die before the primaries come to an end

If one of them dies or is incapacitated before June 25, when the primaries come to an end, some states might postpone their primaries and/or their filing deadlines (as they did in 2020 because of COVID-19) in order to give more time for newer candidates to get into the race, Kamarck says.

If they die after the primaries but before the conventions

If, however, the candidate dies or is incapacitated after June 25, when the primaries are over, and before the parties’ respective conventions (15 to 18 of July for Republicans and 19 to 22 of August for Democrats), the conventions would turn out a bit different.

The conventions

“The convention would become what conventions used to be before reforms made the primaries dominant (minus the smoke-filled rooms”), Kamarck writes jokingly for brookings.edu.

Each party would decide on their new nominee
Delegates would arrive in Milwaukee (for the Republicans) or Chicago (for the Democrats) largely uncommitted. They would then engage in the arduous process of deciding who their nominee should be,” the expert explains.
Each party has different rules

Both Democrats and Republicans have sets of rules governing the functioning of their national committees and the nomination of the president and the vice president, Kamarck says.

“Party business”

But the bottom line, she says, is that the choice of a nominee is “party business”; not state law, not federal law, and not constitutional law.

If they die after the conventions but before Election Day

If the candidate dies or becomes incapacitated after the conventions but before Election Day, the parties would also play a central roll in choosing the new candidate, Lauren Gambino, political correspondent of The Guardian says.

If they die after Election Day

However, if the candidate dies or is incapacitated after Election Day, then the Constitution kicks in. Section 3 of the 20th amendment states: “If, at the time fixed for the beginning of the term of the President, the President elect shall have died, the Vice-President elect shall become President.”

When does a winning candidate become president-elect?

There is some debate however over when a winning candidate becomes president-elect. Is it after the electors vote on 17 December or not until a joint session of Congress counts the electoral votes on 6 January?

There is some ambiguity in the law

The balance of scholarly opinion holds that the president- and vice-president-elect are chosen once the electoral votes are cast, according to a 2020 Congressional Research Service memo, but the law itself is ambiguous, experts say.

A situation that would worsen an already tumultuous election

In conclusion, it’s all about timing and there are some uncertainties that we would only come to know in the actual event of Trump or Biden dying or becoming incapacitated. There is no doubt, however, that a situation like that would just rattle an already tumultuous presidential election.

Never miss a story! Click here to follow The Daily Digest.

More for you