The Battle for Bakhmut has devastated Russian forces, but just how badly?

Here’s what Putin’s campaign to capture Bakhmut has cost him
Comments from Oleksiy Danilov
Bakhumt is surrounded by dead Russians
“No one takes them away
Just Ukrainian propoganda?
Russia is losing more troops than Ukraine
A five-to-one ratio
Western intelligence estimates of Bakhmut's casualty count
Neither side reveals their official death toll
There is no independent count either
We do know that Russia is losing a lot of men
Russia is changing tactics
Moving away from human wave tactics
Trained soliders are flooding in
An opportunity for Ukraine
Here’s what Putin’s campaign to capture Bakhmut has cost him

Vladimir Putin’s relentless desire to capture the Ukrainian city of Bakhmut has devastated Russia’s military forces, but just how bad have the losses been?

Comments from Oleksiy Danilov

During a live telethon in early March, Ukraine’s Secretary of National Security and Defense Council Oleksiy Danilov said Bakhmut was littered with Russian corpses. 

Bakhumt is surrounded by dead Russians

“As reported by Colonel-General Syrskyi, all the alleys and the territory around the city are littered with corpses of Russians, Wagnerians,” Dannilov said.

“No one takes them away"

Danilov added that those Russian and Wagner soldiers lay on Ukrainian land as if they had been sown. “No one takes them away, because no one needs them."

Just Ukrainian propoganda?

While Danilov’s words might seem like fanciful Ukrainian propaganda, there may be some truth behind the claims that Bakhmut is littered with the bodies of Russia’s dead. 

Russia is losing more troops than Ukraine

“Russian forces have lost at least five soldiers for every Ukrainian soldier killed while defending Bakhmut,” wrote Business Insider’s Jishua Zitzer, who was quoting an anonymous NATO official that had spoken with CNN journalists on March 7th. 

A five-to-one ratio

“The official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity,” Zitler added, “said the five-to-one ratio was an informed estimate based on Western intelligence.”

Western intelligence estimates of Bakhmut's casualty count

On March 13th, The Guardian reported that Western intelligence agencies estimated that Russia had suffered at least 20,000-30,000 casualties in their pursuit of Bakhmut.

Neither side reveals their official death toll

The casualty count quoted by The Guardian included Russia's dead but figuring out just how many Russians have died fighting to conquer Bakhmut is difficult to know since neither side has revealed their offical counts.

There is no independent count either

“No independent count of the dead and wounded has been possible, and each side is seen as inflating the other’s losses while concealing its own,” wrote New York Times journalist Andre Kramer.

We do know that Russia is losing a lot of men

What we do know is that Russia has lost a significant number of men during their Bakhmut offensive and they might not all have been Yegeny Priozhin’s ill-trained and ill-equipped Wager prisoner recruits.

 

Russia is changing tactics

The Head of Ukraine’s Office of the President Mykhailo Podolyak recently sat down with Italy’s La Stampa newspaper and revealed that Russia has changed tactics in Bakhmut.

Moving away from human wave tactics

"Russia has changed tactics," Podolyak said, referencing the move away from the Wagner Group’s human wave tactics that had been so successful until now. 

Trained soliders are flooding in

"It has converged on Bakhmut with a large part of its trained military personnel, the remnants of its professional army, as well as the private companies."

"We have two objectives"

"We, therefore, have two objectives: to reduce their capable personnel as much as possible, and to fix them in a few key wearisome battles, to disrupt their offensive and concentrate our resources elsewhere, for the spring counter-offensive.”

An opportunity for Ukraine

If Podolyak’s statement proves true, Ukrainian forces may have been provided with an invaluable opportunity to destroy some of Russia’s best soldiers and equipment, something Putin can ill afford as the conflict's initiative turns back towards Ukraine. 

More for you