Black Sea mystery: A closer look at a puzzling naval incident involving Russia

Weird Black Sea ship movements
Is the Russian Navy hiding from Ukrainian drones?
The incident puzzled some war analysts
An incident that got many officials wondering
Escort ships acting outside of the ordinary
The ships abruptly turned back around
Were the ships worried about an attack?
The vessels were hiding in Turkish waters
They didn’t take the shortest route possible
Black Sea victories are a standout success
Ukraine's asymmetrical alternatives changed things
Russia was forced to reassess its appetite for risk
Ukraine’s non-conventional approach is working
Ukraine dominates the western Black Sea
Does this explain those weird ship movements?
The most recent victim of Ukrainian sea drones
No Russian ship can hide in the Black Sea
Things have changed six months
The last patrol boat left Crimea in July
Russia naval losses so far
Weird Black Sea ship movements

In March 2024, Ukraine appeared to be gaining the upper hand in the battle for the Black Sea, but a peculiar incident sparked curiosity about the activities of the Russian Navy in the area.

Is the Russian Navy hiding from Ukrainian drones?

Ukraine may not have made real progress with its counteroffensive during the summer of 2023, but Kyiv did achieve some big victories on the Black Sea at that time, and those victories continued into 2024. 

 

 

The incident puzzled some war analysts

One interesting incident on the Black Sea in March 2024 indicated that the Ukrainians might been making more progress against Moscow than was reported at the time, and it left some war analysts puzzled. 

An incident that got many officials wondering

Ukrainian Navy spokesperson Dmytro Pletenchuk revealed that a group of Russian ships near the Bosporus Strait had acted strangely while they had escorted a ship to the vital global trade waterway. 

 

Escort ships acting outside of the ordinary

"Recently, an interesting incident occurred when they sent two ship units to escort their vessels from the Bosporus. That doesn't happen often, only about once a month,” said Pletenchuk before revealing more details. 

Photo Credit: Twitter @YorukIsik

The ships abruptly turned back around

“But at some point, they just turned around and headed back," Pletenchuk explained to the Ukrainian News outlet Unian according to Newsweek. What prompted the two ships to turn around was not known, but there were some theories. 

Photo Credit: Twitter @YorukIsik

Were the ships worried about an attack?

Pletenchuk speculated that the commander of the ships may have received information that they were in danger and went on to explain that the route they had taken in Turkish territorial waters was outside of the norm for Russia. 

The vessels were hiding in Turkish waters

“These vessels were forced to move along the Turkish border,” Pletenchuk explained to the Ukrainian news outlet, adding that the ships were hiding in Turkish territorial waters rather than taking a direct route to their destination. 

They didn’t take the shortest route possible

“Thus not taking the shortest route, which they would normally take, but instead fleeing to their hiding spots," Pletenchuk added, hinting that the vessels may have been hiding from Ukrainian naval drones, which dominated the sea at that time and continued to do so today. 

Black Sea victories are a standout success

Business Insider’s Rebecca Roman noted at the time that Kyiv's success in the Black Sea theatre had been one of Ukraine's “standout successes of the two-year-long war,” and much of that success was due to the country’s use of powerful new naval drones. 

Ukraine's asymmetrical alternatives changed things

The British Ministry of Defence reported on February 25th, 2024 that at the outset of the war in Ukraine, Russia had the freedom to navigate throughout the whole of the Black Sea but Kyiv’s use of asymmetrical alternatives changed things. 

Russia was forced to reassess its appetite for risk

Russia was forced to reassess its appetite for risk and relocated its main operating area to the Eastern Black Sea. Persistent attacks on Russian naval assets have put Moscow on the back foot and made Russia far more cautious.

Ukraine’s non-conventional approach is working

The British Ministry of Defence noted that “it is increasingly evident that the defensive posture adopted to mitigate against Ukraine's non-conventional approach to maritime warfare is not working as intended.”

Photo Credit: Wiki Commons by Автор: Ssu.gov.ua, CC BY 4.0

Ukraine dominates the western Black Sea

“At a strategic level, Ukraine's approach has denied Russia the ability to interfere with its maritime trade routes,” the defense ministry report explained. “Ukraine's momentum has allowed it to dominate the western Black Sea.”

Does this explain those weird ship movements?

Ukraine's domination of the Black Sea in March 2024 may have explained why the two Russian vessels traveling in Turkish territorial waters at the start of March were acting so strangely. They may have indeed been trying to avoid being attacked. 

The most recent victim of Ukrainian sea drones

On March 5th, the Russian patrol vessel Sergei Kotov became one of the latest ships at that time to be sunk by Ukrainian naval drones in an attack that officials in Kyiv claim killed seven sailors and sent the Sergei Kotov to the bottom of the Black Sea. 

Photo Credit: Twitter @ZelenskyyUa
"Right now this ship is on the seabed,"

"Right now this ship is on the seabed," Dmytro Pletenchuk said according to BBC News, adding that a Russian helicopter may also have been aboard the ship when it was sunk by Ukrainian naval drones. 

Photo Credit: Wiki Commons Main Directorate of Intelligence, CC BY 4.0

No Russian ship can hide in the Black Sea

"There are no safe havens for Russian terrorists in the Black Sea and nor will there be," Volodymyr Zelesnky said on March 5th. Ukrainian intelligence reported that Sergei Kotov was destroyed by five Magura V5 sea drones. 

Photo Credit: Wiki Commons СпецТехноЕкспорт

Things have changed six months

More than six months on from March, the Ukrainians have only increased their hold on the Black Sea. In July, Russia pulled its last naval patrol ship out of its port in Crimea according to Reuters.

The last patrol boat left Crimea in July

"The last patrol ship of the Black Sea Fleet of the Russian Federation is bolting from our Crimea just now. Remember this day," Navy spokesman Dmytro Pletenchuk claimed in a post on Facebook. However, it was not clear at the time if that move was permanent.

Russia naval losses so far

As of October 9th, Russia has lost 28 naval ships and submarines since the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, 21 were destroyed and  7 were damaged, according to the Dutch open-source intelligence firm Oryx.

Never miss a story! Click here to follow The Daily Digest.

More for you